Health Determinants: Take II 
(editorial)

Marie Carlson, MA, Alberta Centre for Well-Being


 

In the spring of 1997, we asked readers, "What do you need to be healthy?" This was WellSpring's first introduction of the concept "Determinants of Health" and marked a shift in Alberta Centre for Well-Being's thinking about physical activity, active living and health.

"Health Determinants" is the generic term given to the full range of personal, social, economic and environmental factors known to have a bearing on health1. These factors, most of which fall outside the health care sector, do not act in isolation; their complex interactions have a significant impact on the health status of individuals and populations. Between four and twelve health determinants are identified in the literature, depending on the source. Health Canada's Population Health Promotion (PHP)2 model is frequently cited, and researchers agree that the following list of health determinants is a well-documented starting point.3  


Twelve Determinants of Health

Income and Social Status
Social Support Networks
Education and Lifelong Learning
Employment and Working Conditions
Social Environments 
Physical Environments 
Biology and Genetic Endowment 
Personal Health Practices and Coping Skills 
Healthy Child Development 
Health Services
Gender
 
Culture


This issue of WellSpring emphasizes important implications of health determinants for physical activity and Active Living. Taking a national lead, the Coalition for Active Living has recently published the Position Statement on Physical Inactivity, which provocatively re-frames the problem of physical inactivity from a personal to a public health perspective. The paper calls for broader intersectoral strategies that balance individual behavior change strategies with environmental strategies for change. The Coalition's goal is to create social and physical environments that foster greater physical activity participation for all.

Our Research Corner focuses on the influence of income, one of the most challenging determinants, for physical activity participation of Albertans. Of interest to practitioners, Tish Doyle-Baker reflects on the usefulness of the health-determinants concept for educating fitness leaders, and poses important questions about future leadership training programs that build on this perspective. At the organizational level, Rick Turnbull, shows how the Canadian Intramural Recreation Association strives to make policy and practical links between intramurals, recreation and determinants of health. Emma Smith explores the challenges of biological-based barriers and affirms the benefits of being active, despite limiting conditions or disabilities. Sandy O'Brien Cousins identifies the physical activity patterns and health status of North American minority groups. Highlighting gender and culture, Sandy suggests that the restoration of active traditions may be the key to promoting healthy Active Living within diverse population groups in contemporary times. Last, our Snapshots highlight exemplary provincial and national research projects that tackle the influence of health determinants in the workplace, for low-income women, families living on welfare, and for recreations programs, facilities and services country-wide.

Health Determinants is a challenging concept to incorporate into traditional thinking and practice around physical activity and Active Living where the behavioral approach is especially entrenched. Evidence-based and community driven, however, this perspective reflects the new way of doing business in health promotion. Ideally, by working across the many determinants or by simply adding one or more (beyond personal health practices and coping skills) to our professional practice, we improve the chances of creating and sustaining a physically active way of life for all.

Check the Implications for Practice boxes throughout this issue to get you started thinking about health determinants where you work, volunteer and play. 

Suggested reading
For more information about the determinants of health, see the following readings:

  • Hamilton, N. & Bhatti, T. (1996). Population health promotion: An integrated model of population health and health promotion. Ottawa, ON: Health Canada.

  • On ecological perspectives read Sallis, J.F. & Owen, N. (1996). Ecological Models in K. Glanz, F.M. Lewis & B.K. Rimer (Eds.), Health behaviour education: Theory, research and practice 2nd ed. (pp. 403-424). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.

  • Green L.W., Richard, L. & Potvin, L. (1996) Ecological Foundations of Health Promotion. American Journal of Health Promotion, vol. 10 (4): 270-281. Special Issue on Social Ecology.

  • Frankish, C. J., Milligan, C. D., & Reid, C. (1998). A review of relationships between active living and determinants of health. Social Science and Medicine. 47 (3):287-301. 

References

  1. World Health Organization. (1998). Health promotion glossary. Geneva:Author

  2. Hamilton, N. & Bhatti, T. (1996). Population health promotion: An integrated model of population health and health promotion. Ottawa, ON: Health Canada.

  3. Thurston, W. E., et al. (1999) Health promotion effectiveness in Alberta: Providing tools for healthy Albertans. (p.34) Calgary, AB: Alberta Health and Wellness. 


Twelve Determinants of Health

Income and Social Status
Adequate income is related to better health. People with more income can afford better housing, food, clothing and necessities than people with low income. Individuals from high income/status households have different socialization experiences than those living in low income/status households. Research shows that income can affect health by increasing opportunities, choices and a sense of control in one's life. Health improves with each step up the income and social ladder. 

Social Support Networks 
A social support network means having family, friends and community resources available to provide both encouragement and help in accessing resources. To increase their health, people need to be in contact with others. Communities give people a sense of belonging, plus opportunities to give and receive help. 

Education and Lifelong Learning
All individuals should have access to educational opportunities that help them achieve their personal goals and contribute to society. Education improves our health by providing us with greater access to information or problem solving skills, and by increasing opportunities for better jobs and job security.

Employment and Working Conditions
People spend a great part of their lives working. A person's employment history and benefits received has a major impact on the resources available to them during retirement. Unemployment and underemployment are both associated with poorer health, as is work-related stress and job insecurity.  

Social Environments
The importance of social support also extends to the broader community. Civic vitality refers to the strength of social networks within a community, region, province or country. It is reflected in the institutions, organizations and informal giving practices that people create to share resources and build attachments to others.

Physical Environments
Physical environments include both the natural (the outdoors) and built or "man-made" settings (buildings, cities, communities, etc.). Factors in each of these settings such as pollution of air, water or soil, crowding, road design, and safety features are important influences on health. Environments where we live, work and play should be free of hazards and toxins, and be health promoting.

Biology and Genetic Endowment
The basic biology and organic make-up of the human body are a fundamental determinant of health. Genetic endowments are the physical qualities or traits and pre-dispositions toward certain diseases or conditions that are inherited through one's genes. An individual's genetic endowment along with the biological differences between the sexes influences health on an individual and population basis.

Personal Health Practices and Coping Skills
Personal health practices include the things we do to prevent disease and optimize good health such a nutritious diet, exercise, and avoidance of harmful substances. Coping skills are how we deal with stress such as the pressures of life, personal relationships, and health conditions. Environments and opportunities that promote positive personal health practices and coping skills allow up to make healthy choices and assist us in dealing with the pressures of life. 

Healthy Child Development
The promotion of health and well-being for life has its roots in early childhood. The effect of pre-natal and early childhood conditions and experiences on subsequent health, well-being, coping skills and competence is powerful. Habits and patterns established early on contribute to later health status, making it important to provide an positive supportive environment for a child's growth and development.

Health Services
Health services help to take care of an individual's mind and body. Some examples are counseling services, clinics and hospitals. The health care system is concerned with the maintenance and enhancement of health, as well as treatment and rehabilitation. Health services that promote and maintain health and prevent disease can influence the overall health of a community.

Gender 
Gender refers to the array of socially constructed identities, personal qualities and traits, attitudes, behaviors, values, relative power and influence that society ascribes to the two sexes on a differential basis, with differing results. Gender roles are learned, reinforced and reproduced through socialization in the family, other institutions and cultural values. "Gendered" norms influence the health system's practices and priorities. Many health issues are a function of gender-based social status or roles. For example, until recently, researchers knew more about causes and treatments for heart disease in men than for women, which are less researched and understood. 

Culture
Peoples' customs, traditions, and the beliefs of their family and community all affect their health.  Some persons or groups may face additional health risks due to an environment which is largely determined by dominant cultural values that contribute to the perpetuation of conditions such as marginalization, stigmatization, loss or devaluation of language and culture, and lack of access to culturally appropriate health care and services.


                                                                                Health Podium